How to select an arborist
The most common abuse of a tree is a practice called "topping" in which the outer part of the branches is cut off. This has several bad effects. It deprives the tree of leaves, starving it and making it more susceptible to insects and fungi. Since most of a branch is intact, the sap continues to flow to the end of the branch, encouraging new growth to be small, weak bushy sprouts at the end of the cut branches. The new weak branches shade each other and are ugly.
Branches should be removed so that relatively few, large branches remain. The branches that remain should retain most of their leaves. Ideally, the tree will be shaped away from wires, buildings and human spaces. It should become more open and yet remain natural-looking.
Finally, most of the "arborists" that are unskilled-enough to top a tree, also fail to protect the heartwood with paint or pitch. Most often they leave it exposed to rain, rot and boring insects.
Correct trimming removes smaller branches near the trunk. A cut should be made vertically or be slightly overhung to keep water out of the heartwood. Bare heartwood should be painted to discourage insects and rot. The paint is more critical as the cut is closer to the trunk, and heartwood or the climate is more wet. Some trees have wet heartwood, and a cut must be painted or pitched.
A professional arborist will not leave branches on the ground, to be a safety hazard or nuisance. If he cuts down a tree, he will know how to remove stumps. He will also have a truck with a chipper, and clean up after himself.
Lastly, be sure to ask if the arborist carries insurance. In some jurisdictions, unless you make other arrangements, as his employer you will be responsible for his care if he has an accident while climbing your tree. If he is going to remove a tree near a building, be sure he is bonded.
Legal issues
Depending on legal jurisdiction, there are a number of legal issues surrounding the practices of arborists and of urban tree management in general:
- ownership of trees on or near boundaries - neighbours may have legal rights regarding trees which adjoin or overhang their property.
- "right to light" - some jurisdictions grant property owners rights to enjoy a "reasonable" amount of sunlight, and neighbouring trees which deny this may be subject to trimming or felling as a consequence.
- structural impact - the growth of tree roots (or their removal) may affect the stability of nearby walls or building foundations. Equally, unstable, diseased or dead trees may fall, causing structural damage or personal injury.
- control of disease - in an attempt to control epidemics of tree diseases or agricultural pests, many jurisdictions require property owners to ensure their trees are healthy and that rot and disease are controlled.
- conservation - in many locations, certain trees are protected (often on a basis of species or size), requiring a specific permission be obtained before they are felled or radically trimmed.
- safety - property owners are generally liable for injuries arising from unsafe trees or tree branches, and may also be liable for the safety of arborists working on their trees