Table of contents |
|
Problems with wind bands/wind band instruments
The Oboe
Many smaller bands with an oboist often find that (depending on the skill of the player, of course) the oboe does not blend well with other instruments, especially as amatuer oboists frequently produce a very loud, strident tone that suffers from bad intonation in the higher registers. If this is the case, the oboe may be kept silent when there are not many other instruments playing. If the oboe must play a solo, it may be softened with two flutes, one at the same pitch as the oboe, and one an octave higher.
The Clarinet
Throughout its history, the clarinet has always been beset with problems of fingering, making playing in extreme keyss (or even moderatley difficult keys) difficult to the point of being impossible. For that reason, clarinets have been made in several keys (mostly B flat for flat keys and A for sharp keys). Unfortunately, not many amatuer clarinettists own instruments in A, and there are few wind band parts calling for them. Also, larger or smaller instruments than the type B-flat clarinet are only made in one key (sopranino, alto, bass, contra-alto, contrabass). So this restricts wind bands from using many "acceptable" key signatures (for instance, to play in concert D, a B flat clarinet has to play in E, and an E flat instrument in B!). There is no solution to this problem. Also, many beginner clarinettists are much averse to playing "on the break", so when arranging/composing it is important to write either above or below the break, and avoid using the written B above written middle C as much as possible.
The Tuba
The major problem with the tuba is that its valves are frequently out of tune with one another. As the tuba rarely plays solo, this is not a serious problem, but when directing a wind band it is important that the tuba player be aware of this. Using tubas equipped with four or more valves greatly helps.