Each show opened with a jovial greeting from the host, Raymond, played initially by Raymond Edward Johnson and then by Paul McGrath beginning in 1945. Speaking in an exaggeratedly "spooky" voice, Raymond would spout jokes and puns over a melodramatic organ score that one can easily imagine being played by a skeleton. As the series progressed, even the advertisers would get into the act, trading banter with Raymond before the story proper began.
Its campy comedy notwithstanding, the stories were often effective little chillers, mixing horror and humor in equal doses. Memorable episodes include "Terror by Night" (9/18/45) and "The Tell-Tale Heart" (8/3/41) with Boris Karloff. Quite a number of established stars appeared over the years, such as Karloff, Peter Lorre, Richard Widmark, and Mary Astor.