Elefante, along with founding Kansas members Kerry Livgren and Dave Hope, left the Kansas band in 1984. All three by that point had become born again Christians, and began recording contemporary Christian music after leaving Kansas. Livgren and Hope formed the band AD, while Elefante pursued a solo career. John Elefante, along with his brother Dino Elefante, also became noted as record producers for a number of contemporary Christian recording artists.