He died unmarried, at which time the Earldom of Castlehaven and the Barony of Audley of Hely became extinct. The Barony of Audley created by writ of 1312 is deemed to have devolved upon his nephew, son of his sister Elizabeth, namely George Thicknesse, later Thicknesse-Touchet.
{| border="2" align="center"
|-
|width="30%" align="center" rowspan="2"|Preceded by:
James Tuchet
|width="40%" align="center"|Earl of Castlehaven
|width="30%" align="center"|Followed by:
Extinct
|-
|width="40%" align="center"|Baron Audley
|width="30%" align="center"|Followed by:
George Thicknesse-Touchet
|}