| Thomas Willett | 1665-66 |
| Thomas Delavall | 1666-67 |
| Thomas Willett | 1667-68 |
| Cornelius Van Steenwyck | 1668-71 |
| Thomas Delavall | 1671-72 |
| Matthias Nicholls | 1672-73 |
| John Lawrence | 1673-75 |
| William Dervall | 1675-76 |
| Nicholas De Mayer | 1676-77 |
| Stephanus Van Cortlandt | 1677-78 |
| Thomas Delavall | 1678-79 |
| Francis Rombouts | 1679-80 |
| William Dyre | 1680-82 |
| Cornelius Van Steenwyk | 1682-84 |
| Gabriel Minvielle | 1684-85 |
| Nicholas Bayard | 1685-86 |
| Stephanus Van Cortlandt | 1686-88 |
| Peter Delanoy | 1688-91 |
| John Lawrence | 1691-92 |
| Abraham DePeyster | 1692-94 |
| Charles Lodwik | 1694-96 |
| William Merritt | 1696-98 |
| Abraham De Peyster | 1698-99 |
| David Provost | 1699-1700 |
| Isaac De Reimer | 1700-01 |
| Thomas Noell | 1701-02 |
| Thomas Hood | 1702 |
| Phillip French | 1702-03 |
| William Peartree | 1703-07 |
| Ebenezer Wilson | 1707-10 |
| Jacobus Van Cortlandt | 1710-11 |
| Caleb Heathcote | 1711-14 |
| John Johnstone | 1714-19 |
| Jacobus Van Cortlandt | 1719-20 |
| Robert Walters | 1720-25 |
| Johannes Jansen | 1725-26 |
| Robert Lurting | 1726-35 |
| Paul Richard | 1735-39 |
| John Cruger | 1739-44 |
| Stephen Bayard | 1744-47 |
| Edward Holland | 1747-57 |
| John Cruger Jr | 1757-66 |
| Whitehead Hicks | 1766-76 |
| David Matthews | 1776-84 |
| James Duane | 1784-89 |
| Richard Varick | 1789-1801 |
| Edward Livingston | 1801-03 |
| De Witt Clinton | 1803-07 |
| Marinus Willett | 1807-08 |
| De Witt Clinton | 1808-10 |
| Jacob Radcliff | 1810-11 |
| De Witt Clinton | 1811-15 |
| John Ferguson | 1815 |
| Jacob Radcliff | 1815-18 |
| Cadwallader D. Colden | 1818-21 |
| Stephen Allen | 1821-24 |
| William Paulding Jr | 1825-26 |
| Philip Hone | 1826-27 |
| William Paulding Jr | 1827-29 |
| Walter Browne | 1829-33 |
| Gideon Lee | 1833-34 |
| Cornelius Van Wyck Lawrence | 1834-37 |
| Aaron Clark | 1837-39 |
| Isaac L. Varian | 1839-41 |
| Robert Morris | 1841-44 |
| James Harper | 1844-45 |
| William Havemeyer | 1845-46 |
| Andrew H. Mickle | 1846-47 |
| William Brady | 1847-48 |
| William Havemeyer | 1848-49 |
| Caleb Smith Woodhull | 1849-51 |
| Ambrose Kingsland | 1851-53 |
| Jacob Westervelt | 1853-55 |
| Fernando Wood | 1855-58 |
| Daniel F. Tiemann | 1858-60 |
| Fernando Wood | 1860-62 |
| George Opdyke | 1862-64 |
| Charles Gunther | 1864-66 |
| John T. Hoffman | 1866-68 |
| Thomas Coman | 1868 |
| Abraham Oakey Hall | 1869-72 |
| William Havemeyer | 1873-74 |
| Samuel Vance | 1874 |
| William Wickham | 1875-76 |
| Eli Smith Jr | 1877-78 |
| Edward Cooper | 1879-80 |
| William Russell Grace | 1881-82 |
| Franklin Edson | 1883-84 |
| William Russell Grace | 1885-86 |
| Abram S. Hewitt | 1887-88 |
| Hugh L. Grant | 1889-92 |
| Thomas F. Gilroy | 1893-94 |
| William L. Strong | 1895-97 |
| Robert A. Van Wyck | 1898-1901 |
| Seth Low | 1902-03 |
| George Brinton McClellan Jr | 1904-09 |
| William Jay Gaynor | 1910-13 |
| Ardolph Loges Kline | 1913 |
| John Purroy Mitchell | 1914-17 |
| John F. Hylan | 1918-25 |
| James J. Walker | 1926-32 |
| Joseph V. McKee | 1932 |
| John P. O'Brien | 1933 |
| Fiorello H. LaGuardia | 1934-45 |
| William O'Dwyer | 1946-50 |
| Vincent R. Impellitteri | 1950-53 |
| Robert F. Wagner Jr | 1954-65 |
| John V. Lindsay | 1966-73 |
| Abraham D. Beame | 1974-77 |
| Edward I. Koch | 1978-89 |
| David N. Dinkins | 1990-93 |
| Rudolph W. Giuliani | 1994-2001 |
| Michael R. Bloomberg | 2002- |