Kelli's amicable departure, while lamented by many, was well received by critics who felt that it gave the band a more honest, emotional timbre. It has also helped curb the inevitable comparisons with Portishead. The band felt that Chris' vocals would be a better fit for Chris' lyrics. Consensus amongst fans is that the songs since Becoming X have lost the sometimes creepy bubblegum feel, but have gained an emotional intensity beyond what Kelli's could provide.