Of the 285 people on the train that night, 134 survived and 151 died. Of those that died 20 bodies were never recovered, it is believed they were washed out to sea.
Evidence given at the commission of enquiry into the disaster revealed that the midstream piers of the railway bridge had been undermined by previous sudden floods, from as early as 1925. While large concrete blocks, weighing several tons, had been placed around the footings of these piers and the space between the blocks and the piers backfilled with gravel, the lahar was strong enough to sweep these away.
The cause of the lahar that lead to the disaster was believed to be the overtopping and sudden collapse of a natural volcanic ash dam that had blocked the outlet of the crater lake on top of Mount Ruapehu. When that dam collapsed, the water from the lake mixed with the material from the ash dam and rushed down the mountainside in a flash flood known as a lahar. Until this disaster, the danger posed by lahars from Mount Ruapehu was only appreciated by a few scientist. A lahar warning system was subsequently installed to alert railway controllers of high river flows.