Taylor asked friends Lynn Nichols (from the 1970's Phil Keaggy band), Dave Perkins, bassist Wade Jaynes and drummer Mike Mead.
The band first appeared on the soundtrack to the motion picture Pump Up The Volume with a song called "Tale O' The Twister". The band's only album was released on MCA Records in 1991 and was well received by music critics and MTV. Although the band had already begun to record a second album, MCA Records went through some restructuring and dropped the band before it could be released.
Chagall Guevara disbanded some time later, but they did reunite temporarily in 1994 to record a song for a tribute to Mark Heard, entitled Strong Hand of Love.