In the United States, the awarding of the Most Valuable Player Award (or MVP) in Major League Baseball has changed hands several times but since the 1930s has been one of the better-implemented awards in baseball.
Table of contents |
2 League Awards (1922-1929) 3 BBWAA Awards (1931-present) |
The Chalmers Automobile Company awarded an automobile in 1910 to the batting average leader in each league. This led to a contoversy in the American League; Ty Cobb and Napoleon Lajoie entered the final day of the season neck-and-neck. St. Louis, playing Lajoie's Cleveland team, played their infield back, allowing Lajoie to beat out seven bunt singles in a doubleheader and win the title. In the ensuing debacle, Chalmers awarded automobiles to both players. (The question of who really won the batting title is still debated.)
For 1911, the Chalmers Company decided that batting average was too narrow a focus for an award. The Chalmers Award was the first attempt to recognize a player for overall contributions to his team's success — hence the designation Most Valuable rather than "player of the year", a distinction which remains today.
Chalmers Award (1911-1914)
Year | American League | National League |
---|---|---|
1911 | Ty Cobb, Detroit Tigers, OF | Wildfire Schulte, Chicago Cubs, OF |
1912 | Tris Speaker, Boston Red Sox, OF | Larry Doyle, New York Giants, 2B |
1913 | Walter Johnson, Washington Senators, P | Jake Daubert, Brooklyn Dodgers, 1B |
1914 | Eddie Collins, Philadelphia Athletics, 2B | Johnny Evers, Boston Braves, 2B |
In the 1920s the leagues awarded MVP titles, but limited the ballot options to one player per team, which led to there being no National League MVP in 1922 or 1923. A League Award could also be one by a player only once, leading to unusual results like Babe Ruth's 1927 (one of the greatest offensive seasons of all time) not being eligible for the award. The rule was changed in time for Rogers Hornsby to become the first man to win two MVP awards, in 1929.
League Awards (1922-1929)
Year | American League | National League |
---|---|---|
1922 | George Sisler, St Louis Browns, 1B | No winner |
1923 | Babe Ruth, New York Yankees, OF | No winner |
1924 | Walter Johnson, Washington Senators, P | Dazzy Vance, Brooklyn Dodgers, P |
1925 | Roger Peckinpaugh, Washington Senators, SS | Rogers Hornsby, St. Louis Cardinals, 2B |
1926 | George Burns, Cleveland Indians, 1B | Bob O'Farrell, St. Louis Cardinals, C |
1927 | Lou Gehrig, New York Yankees, 1B | Paul Waner, Pittsburgh Pirates, OF |
1928 | Mickey Cochrane, Philadelphia Athletics, C | Jim Bottomley, St. Louis Cardinals, 1B |
1929 | No winner | Rogers Hornsby, Chicago Cubs, 2B |
In 1931, the Baseball Writers Association of America began awarding the Most Valuable Player trophy.
In 1956 the Cy Young Award was first given to the best pitcher in each league. After that, the belief arose that the Most Valuable Player ought to be a position player, since pitchers had their own award. On occasion, though, pitchers still win the award, and the current rules for the MVP specifically state that pitchers are to be considered.
BBWAA Awards (1931-present)
†Denotes unanimous decision.